Whom does a festival belong to?
As a Malaysian relatively new to Vietnam, Festival Director Associate Professor Lim Kok Yoong acknowledged his position as an outsider and said it had forced him to ask a basic question: “Who does a festival belong to?”
Not, he suggested, to a director or a single institution. A meaningful festival has to belong to the people, communities, practitioners and relationships that give it life. He also resisted the idea that VFCD should distinguish itself simply by becoming “bigger, louder, fancier or more spectacular”.
Instead, the more consequential questions come after people gather and disband: Do relationships continue? Do practices evolve? Do new collaborations emerge? Does the community remain connected? For Associate Professor Lim, recognition cannot be the final objective; the festival must remain useful to the community that gives it life.
The Forum’s international examples showed different ways this might happen.
Mr Gerfried Stocker of Austrian-based Ars Electronica proposed that“a festival has to be a laboratory”, an exceptional space temporarily removed from everyday routines, but one that must still connect back into the city and society. Festivals, he argued, can take risks that more conventional cultural formats cannot, and should continually experiment rather than assume that a final model has been found.
Other provocations widened the conversation further. Ms June Tan, Artistic Director of KL Festival from Malaysia explored festivals as spaces for storytelling, cultural memory and participation rather than passive spectatorship, while Ms Truong Uyen Ly, former director of Hanoi Grapevine situated the discussion within Vietnam’s changing cultural landscape and the practical realities involved in producing creative events — from policy and institutional structures to operational pressures.